John Madden Nicolas Cage Christian Bale David O. Russell Amazon Prime Video Movie Review

Devoid of any revealing themes, engaging personalities or memorable stories, David O. Russell’s drab biopic about the magnetic coach-turned-announcer who gave his name to the popular EA sports game series has the woebegone quality of a cheap biography destined to fill Goodwill bins. “Madden,” produced by Amazon MGM Studios and starring Nicolas Cage in phony makeup, a fat suit and an unconvincing blonde wig, only inspires one to contemplate why it should exist. Little thought has been dedicated to its threadbare script and obvious soundtrack, and even less attention has been paid to its memorable subject. 

“Madden” is the nadir of Russell’s career. He began with “Spanking the Monkey,” launching a run of critical and prestigious highs that included “Three Kings,” “The Fighter,” and “Silver Linings Playbook.” “Accidental Love,” the other competitor for the worst film in his filmography, however, incited a rejection by critics and audiences alike that he’s been incapable of spinning out from with poorly received projects like “Joy” and “Amsterdam”. From Russell’s vantage point, “Madden” must’ve felt like a safe bet for a return to form. But safety is what this unimaginative film possesses with noxious abundance. 

From the outset, Russell attempts an irreverent tone. The film begins with the note: “Not all of this happened but most of it is true” (even the nondescript font choice for this mention is lazy) before launching into a fake documentary about Madden. We’re introduced to our main players: Cage as an unrecognizable copy of the coach, Kathryn Hahn as his oft-ignored wife Virginia, and Christian Bale playing pompous Raiders owner Al Davis. This quick succession of hackneyed impressions, though Cage appears to be trying to emulate the spirit of Madden rather than copying sound or tone, immediately gives rejected SNL skit vibes.

From there, the dull, linear script by Russell and Cambron Clark takes us to the 1976 AFC Championship game between the feared Oakland Raiders and the vaunted Pittsburgh Steelers. Madden as the Raiders’ head coach is a kind of football junkie doubling as a savant. He’s so plugged into the game that in a somewhat fun fourth-wall break that sees him looking in his fridge toward the viewer, he explains to us the X’s and O’s of a play he wants to run later that day. Madden and Al Davis have not only never won a Super Bowl together, they’re 0-5 in championship contests. They want the kind of glory that’ll grant them immortality in the hall of fame, which they imagine as a heaven where the greats spend eternity talking with each other.

Due to several low-hanging creative decisions, the action in and around the football games isn’t particularly engaging. For Madden’s car ride to the Oakland Coliseum, Russell plops down the Chambers Brothers’ “Time Has Come Today.” When Willie Hall intercepts Terry Bradshaw, the Hollies’ “Long Cool Woman (In a Black Dress)” plays because the Raiders wear black. Freeze frames with circles drawn in silver highlighting individual plays recall Madden’s talent for breaking down sequences while the integration of actual game footage hopes to lend tangibility to these recreations. But we never see the crowd’s reactions to these plays, just close-ups and medium shots of Virginia, Madden’s two sons, and his next-door neighbor Vince McGary (Shane Gillis) reacting from the stands. Without actually seeing the crowd, its rhythms and reactions, the game feels like a tawdry simulation.

Russell tries, with little success, to use Madden’s run to his lone Super Bowl title as a crossroads for the coach. A neglected Virginia begs her husband to pay attention to their family. Davis wants more championships even if it means risking the health of a burned out Madden, who’s battling a bleeding ulcer. At a Super Bowl afterparty, Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney) of EA also approaches him about the prospects of producing an NFL video game. All of these factors, which cause Madden to retire from coaching to become a broadcaster and television personality, aren’t strong enough on their own or together, for that matter, to tell us anything revealing about Madden. 

Instead, Russell’s film is what I’ve taken to calling “interview biopics.” They’ll tell you every useless detail about the person, where they come from and their biggest accomplishments, but when it comes to asking them what their biggest flaw is, the subject can only say: “I care too much.” When “Madden” attempts to be a buddy movie about his unlikely friendship with Davis, few scrabbles occur between them. Virginia can’t quite leave Madden because she loves his passion. Even a television broadcast gone wrong with Pat Summerall (Joel Murray) is resolved quickly. Most of these things happened, which isn’t to say the film needs to manufacture storylines, but what is brought up should inspire complex feelings or thoughts to emanate from the subject, revealing something, anything about him. Russell, unfortunately, just isn’t interested. 

No one in the cast seems capable of adding any further insight. Cage appears disengaged from the flat material, unable to actualize what makes Madden interesting: his larger-than-life personality, endearing eccentricities and surprising intensity. Bale latches onto even less, opting for chewing scenery rather than conjuring any believable emotion. Hahn and Sienna Miller, who plays Davis’ wife Carol, gamely suffer through their one-note experience, while Mulaney arrives with nothing to offer. In one telling scene, Madden arrives to see the game Mulaney’s character has been designing, only to be infuriated when all the players look like indistinguishable pixels. It’s a description that aptly sums up “Madden.”    

Robert Daniels

Robert Daniels is Associate Editor at RogerEbert.com, and has written for the New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, Reverse Shot, Screen Daily, and the Criterion Collection. He has covered film festivals ranging from Cannes to Sundance to Toronto to the Berlinale and Locarno. He lives in Chicago, and is a member of the Chicago Film Critics Association.

Madden (2026)

Amazon Prime
Thumbs down rating
110 minutes ‧ R ‧ 2026

Cast

subscribe icon

The best movie reviews, in your inbox