The Mule repeatedly spells out and hammers home its message about the importance of family, but it ultimately rings hollow.
Werner Herzog asks several interview subjects in his latest documentary the same fantastic question: “Does the internet dream of itself?” It’s a question only Herzog would or could ask, but it’s indicative of his approach to the subject matter overall. He’s not interested in the nuts and bolts of the history or even future of technology, but its human impact. Herzog has always been a deeply human filmmaker, one captivated by behavior and man’s relation to the natural world more than mere details. It’s that approach that makes “Lo and Behold” a deeply Herzogian film, a study of how the invention of the internet in 1969 forever changed the course of human evolution, and how we are still relatively in the dark ages of technology.
The title is explained in the first segment—the film is divided into ten with Herzogian titles like “The Internet of Me”—as we learn about the first interaction between a computer at UCLA and one 400 miles away at Stanford. The two computers were supposed to combine to form the word “LOGIN,” with UCLA sending “LOG” and Stanford adding the “IN.” The server crashed after the first two letters, meaning that the first transmission from computer to computer was “LO,” as in “Lo and Behold.” Of course, Herzog is the kind of filmmaker who loves this kind of synergy in which it feels like randomness is commenting on the future. It’s only the beginning of a film that could only have been made by one man, a movie that seeks to offer insight into the connectivity provided by the internet but does so through the lens of a humanist.
Essentially, “Lo and Behold” is a series of interviews with people who have more insight into technology and its impact on the human race than you do. However, it’s not a cold, talking-head documentary that seeks to chronicle how we got from “LO” to autonomous cars. It is a playful exploration of the daily impact of technology. Herzog starts by examining the internet as a connective, positive force, a way to develop communities and solve problems. But he’s not afraid of the dark side of the web either, relatively quickly turning to a truly disturbing story of a family who suffered when a paramedic took a picture of a decapitated family member at the scene of the crime and then put it online. Shortly after a man talks about the power of the internet to cure illness and provide education, we’re hearing from a mother who understandably calls it the Antichrist. This is the reality of technology—it is everything.
And that aspect of it allows Herzog to run wild with ideas that interest him. He talks to people about autonomous cars that ping lasers off what’s around them to satellites and back down again so they don’t hit anything. He films a soccer match between robots who are being developed at such a rate that their creators are planning for the day that they’ll be able to beat the FIFA World Cup winning team. He speaks to people who have moved close to a NORAD satellite that requires a technological blackout within a ten-mile radius. These people believe that the waves from satellites and cell phones are making them sick (kind of like Michael McKean's character in "Better Call Saul") and find solitude in this rare, isolated community. Herzog allows time for such a variety of voices, from the hacker who obtained Motorola’s source code merely to prove he could do so to Elon Musk, who wants to send people to Mars and is working on that project right now. Herzog's approach is like a tapestry with each section and interview working like a patch instead of directly commenting on each other.
To that end, “Lo and Behold” may feel a little disjointed to some viewers, but I think that approach is entirely intentional and effective. As Herzog says in the beginning, we have only scratched the surface of what technology will do for future generations. By the end, he’s speaking to people who are convincingly making the case that we will someday be able to tweet thoughts. He’s taken us on a ten-chapter journey from “LO” to a future we can’t even really picture. As the film points out, when people imagined the future in science fiction of the past they more often pictured flying cars than the connectivity of the world wide web. So it’s unlikely that we even know what’s next. I just hope Herzog is around to offer his take on it.
The staff choices for the best films of 2018.
A review of Fallout 76.
This message came to me from a reader named Peter Svensland. He and a fr...
The ten best films of 2018, as chosen by Peter Sobczynski.