There’s something to be said for giving an audience exactly
what it wants for Christmas. When you fire up something called “A Very Murray
Christmas,” and you know it’s directed by Sofia Coppola, you have a certain set
of expectations: Bill Murray should be droll, sarcastic and sing a few holiday
tunes. Jason Schwarztman should be involved, as should a few other celebrity
guest stars. The music choices should range from traditional (“The Little
Drummer Boy”) to wonderfully unexpected (“Fairytale of New York,” one of my
personal favorites songs of all time). And there should be a hip band at some
point—in this case, Phoenix. “A Very Murray Christmas” is so much of what Bill
Murray and Sofia Coppola fans would expect it to be that it’s almost perfect.

The set-up is wonderfully simple. Bill Murray has to do a
Christmas special on the night of a major blizzard, and so none of his
celebrity friends are willing to show up for the show. It’s going to be a
disaster, as a forlorn Murray in reindeer ears singing “Christmas Blues” with
Paul Shaffer on piano sets the tone. Michael Cera and Amy Poehler play
behind-the-scenes players trying to keep Murray from backing out of his
contracted special. Cera is particularly hilarious, scoffing at the idea that
Murray’s friend George Clooney is the only star who might stop by: “You saw “Monuments Men”?” “I was in it.”

Murray ends up bumping into Chris Rock, and basically kidnaps
him to sing a hysterical “Little Drummer Boy” before the power mercifully goes
out and Murray and Shaffer retire to a nearby bar for the bulk of the special.
Buster Poindexter tends bar (“Scrooged” reunion!) and Rashida Jones and
Schwartzman play a struggling couple upset that no one could get through the
snow to their wedding. And there’s a lot of music, including Phoenix, and
others.

“A Very Murray Christmas” is really like those old variety
specials that we don’t see any more filtered through both Murray and Coppola’s
sensibilities. It is deadly droll—one of those entertainment items for which if
you’re not on its comedy wavelength in the first five minutes, you’re not going
to change your mind. However, if you are already smiling at Murray in his sad
reindeer ears, as I was, you’re likely to be grinning ear to ear by the time
his “Monuments Men” co-star shows up with a pop princess. Santa got my letters.

Brian Tallerico

Brian Tallerico is the Managing Editor of RogerEbert.com, and also covers television, film, Blu-ray, and video games. He is also a writer for Vulture, The Playlist, The New York Times, and GQ, and the President of the Chicago Film Critics Association.

Leave a comment

subscribe icon

The best movie reviews, in your inbox