Roger Ebert Home

Will "Mean Girl" Palin herself appear on SNL?

And, if she does, how many viewers will be able to tell the difference? Is this gonna be the talent portion?

Bill Zwecker reports in the Chicago Sun-Times:

It's looking more and more likely that Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin will appear on ''Saturday Night Live'' -- to have some fun with Tina Fey.

As the comedian's impressions of the GOP vice presidential candidate draw laughs from Republicans and Democrats alike, a top honcho from the John McCain campaign tells me there's a debate going on about how to respond.

[...] While next weekend's ''Saturday Night Live'' will be a rerun, it is possible Palin could appear Thursday on the first of NBC's ''Weekend Update'' specials in prime time.


After the SNL VP debate sketch Saturday night/Sunday morning, I wrote:

Something strange is happening, though: Fey's Palin is not only sharper and funnier than Palin's Palin, she's also more vivid, more... real (maybe because she's on TV more). It's as if she's the main Palin and the other one is the paler surrogate Palin.

So, what would happen if the two of them actually appeared together? My theory: Matter and anti-matter will collide and end the universe.

Of course, Hillary Clinton appeared with Amy Poehler's Hillary Clinton, Joe Pesci appeared with Jim Breuer's Joe Pesci, and so on.

But the connection between Pey and Falin Fey and Palin may be deeper than most realize. Several women have told me that Palin has been haunting their nightmares in ways no other electoral candidate ever has, and a reader of Andrew Sullivan's "The Daily Dish" believes she understands why -- and it has to do with a 2004 movie scripted by Tina Fey:

... I just want to point out that women of any intelligence recognize Palin as a female archetype we've had to deal with for years. In modern vernacular, she's a "mean girl," who is ambitious and has no trouble stabbing people in the back to get what she wants. This type of woman is terribly divisive, splitting women between adoring acolytes who want to be "just like them" and women who see clearly what's going on and can't believe that no one else (especially males) can see through it. [...]

[During the VP debate:] You could almost hear a collective embarrassed groan from educated, non-neoconservative women all over the world who have worked their asses off to be taken seriously only to have this bimbo blatantly and on camera attempt to reduce the role of women to their ability to flirt.

How mean is she? How unserious? From The Independent, October 6, 2008:

In remarks seen to have a racial edge, she said of Mr Obama: "This is not a man who sees America as you and I see America. We see America as a force for good in this world. We see America as a force for exceptionalism ... Our opponents see America as imperfect enough to pal around with terrorists who would bomb their own country."

The "friend of a terrorist" allegation appeared to have scant basis in fact, but succeeded in grabbing the news agenda, suggesting the McCain camp will now make attacks on his opponent's character and personality a key feature of the campaign in the final month of the race for the White House.

What do you think: At this point in the campaign, should SNL put Palin on the show?

Latest blog posts

Latest reviews

Back to Black
The Strangers: Chapter 1
The Big Cigar
You Can't Run Forever
In Our Day


comments powered by Disqus