The plot opts for cop-out sentimentality and begins to melt into goo.
I'm double-posting my review of "Skyfall" to encourage comments, which my main site can't accept.
In this 50th year of the James Bond series, with the disappointing "Quantum of Solace" (2008) still in our minds, "Skyfall" triumphantly reinvents 007 in one of the best Bonds ever made. This is a full-blooded, joyous, intelligent celebration of a beloved cultural icon, with Daniel Craig taking full possession of a role he earlier played well in "Casino Royale," not so well in "Quantum"--although it may not have been entirely his fault. I don't know what I expected in Bond #23, but certainly not an experience this invigorating.
The movie's innovations begin in its first shots, which abandon the familiar stalking silhouettes in the iris lens, and hit the ground running. Bond and another agent are in Istanbul, chasing a man who has stolen a crucial hard drive, and after a chase through city streets (involving no less than three Fruit Cart Scenes), 007 is running on top of a train. We know from earlier films that Bond can operate almost anything, but "Skyfall" incredibly has him commandeer a giant Caterpillar and continue the chase by crushing a flatcar stacked with VW Beetles.
It's the kind of absurd stunt we expect in a Bond movie, but this one relies on something unexpected: A dead-serious M (Judi Dench), following the action from MI6 headquarters in London and making a fateful decision. After an enemy agent grabs Bond as a human shield, M's other agent, Eve (Naomie Harris), has both men in her gun sights. The stakes are very high. "Take the shot!" M commands. Bond seems to die, although since this happens around the 20-minute mark we're not very surprised that he doesn't.
M begins to compose the obituary of Commander James Bond, and she might as well also be writing her own. Time has passed her by, she's older, and her new boss Mallory (Ralph Fiennes), convenes a public (!) hearing requiring her to defend her tenure. It's time for a generation to be put out to pasture. Even Q (Ben Whishaw) and, as it turns out, Miss Moneypenny are practically kids.
M is not quite ready to retire, and "Skyfall" at last provides a role worthy of Judi Dench, one of the best actors of her generation. She is all but the co-star of the film, with a lot of screen time, poignant dialogue, and a character who is far more complex and sympathetic than we expect in this series. M for years was a remote and aloof, but she makes the boss vulnerable and fearful that she may have lost her touch. Was her snap decision responsible for the loss of Britain's most valuable secret agent?
The film is guided by a considerable director (Sam Mendes), written by the heavyweights Neal Purvis, Robert Wade and John Logan, and delivers not only a terrific Bond but a terrific movie, period. If you haven't seen a 007 for years, this is the time to jump back in. Although it kneels at some obligatory elements and briefly genuflects at others, it has a spontaneity and emotional sincerity unexpected in a franchise picture; did "The Dark Knight" give it a jolt? If we must look forward to limitless episodes of a franchise, these films and other superhero pictures demonstrate they can also be good films. (For what is 007 if not a superhero?)
There's a theory that you can grade the Bonds on the quality of their villains. In "Skyfall" this is a cerebral megalomanic named Silva, played by Javier Bardem, whose unpronounceable Anton Chigurh in "No Country for Old Men" approached the high-water mark of Hannibal Lector. Here he plays a gay bleached blond computer whiz who stole the drive containing the guarded identities of every MI6 agent. He no longer uses a seductive and treacherous woman to lead Bond astray (and it is too soon for him to test a seductive and treacherous boy).
This is a brand new Bond with love and respect for the old Bond. This is dramatized during Bond's visit to the weathered Scottish mansion inhabited by Kincade (Albert Finney), which has secrets to divulge and continues the movie's rewriting of the character's back story. During the early Bonds, did we ever ask ourselves about 007's origins in life? The movie even produces a moment designed to inspire love in lifetime Bond fans: A reappearance of the Aston Martin DB5 from "Goldfinger," which remains in good operating condition, if you can guess what I mean.
Just as Christopher Nolan gave rebirth to the Batman movies in "The Dark Knight," here is James Bond lifted up, dusted off, set back on his feet and ready for another 50 years. Am I completely misguided when I expect to see Miss Moneypenny become a Bond Girl in the next film?
This message came to me from a reader named Peter Svensland. He and a fr...