I would expect that I would feel more strongly one way or
the other about a musical variation on “The Princess Bride” like ABC’s totally
bizarre and often fascinating “Galavant,” debuting tomorrow night at 7pm CST, and yet my first new show review of 2015 could be summed up as distinctly mixed. “Galavant”
certainly isn’t like anything else currently on network television, which makes
it consistently intriguing in the way anything different from the norm can keep
your attention, and yet it’s also not quite what it should be either. Half the jokes
are inspired; half the jokes hit the floor. The casting is unbalanced, with a few stand-outs and a few bland choices. The music often comes across as more
of a community theatre production than a Broadway sequel to “Spamalot,” another
clear influence. And yet there’s a go-for-broke thing going on here, both in
the cast and crew, that is laudable. So what, a few of the puns crash and burn. So what, it’s
surprisingly grating at times given its short running time. It’s also defiantly
unique. And there’s something nice about starting 2015 with a show that doesn’t
look like anything you watched in 2014.
Did I mention “Galavant” is a half-hour fantasy musical? Cribbing from “Spamalot”
and “The Princess Bride,” “Galavant” has undeniable energy, whether you like it or not. It pummels you with
whimsy and wordplay, most of it courtesy of the brilliant Alan Menken (composer
of “The Little Mermaid” and “Beauty and the Beast”) and Glenn Slater (lyricist
of “Tangled,” another influence with its modern take on fantasy staples). It
comes from the school of comedy in that if you don’t like one joke, all you
need to do is wait a few seconds for the next one. It is often hyperactive,
jumping from joke to musical number to plot point to musical number to bad joke and so on.
It is certainly never boring, but some of the jokes are so purposefully goofy
that more cynical viewers will see their brains through sheer volume of
eye-rolling. When our hero began a training montage with an old-timey score
version of “Eye of the Tiger,” I almost gave up. However, the fact that John
Stamos’ guest star is named Sir Jean Hamm made me laugh even though I knew I
shouldn’t.
The Michael Fassbender-esque Joshua Sasse stars as the title
character, once a dashing hero and now a defeated man. He was in love with the
gorgeous Madalena (Mallory Janson), but she was stolen from him by the
nefarious King Richard (Timothy Omundson)—fans of “The Princess Bride” should
be nodding along about now. Galavant has to return to glory, assisted by a
possible new love interest in the double agent Isabella (Karen David) and a
squire named Sid (Luke Youngblood). All of the above break into song regularly and all of the songs have their tongue in their tuned cheeks, like the second episode closer “Maybe You’re Not the Worst Thing Ever.”
This kind of Fractured Fairy Tale has its audience and its
place, but I’d be lying if I didn’t say I wish “Galavant” was a bit smarter.
Omundson steals most of what I’ve seen, as if he’s in on the joke with his
over-the-top performance more than the other actors. Sasse is a confident lead,
but there’s so little time for actual character here amidst the puns and
musical numbers. Don’t get me wrong. I’m not saying something like “Galavant”
should be “deeper,” but we need to like the characters a bit more than I do
here. “The Princess Bride” is nothing if we don’t love Wesley and Buttercup and
that human, romantic element is what’s missing from “Galavant.” There’s enough to like
here to warrant a look for those who adore its inspirations, but those who can’t
quote “Bride” or walked out of “Spamalot” may want to consider something else
for their first new show of 2015, even if this is like nothing else you’ll see this year.
