Roger Ebert Home

Brian and Charles

There are certain varieties of whimsy that either click with you or don’t. I point this out because what didn’t click for me in “Brian and Charles,” a new comedy directed by Jim Archer, might do something for you. 

We first see Brian, the British comic actor David Earl, in a long shot from the outside, sitting in a shed, working with a welding tool, wearing a mask. In voiceover, Brian talks about how “things had gotten a bit topsy-turvy in my life.” The mask threw me off for a bit—was this to be a Covid-era picture? 

No. Brian’s isolation, and as we see it is not total, stems from being a bit of an oddball of no fixed occupation in rural England. The itinerant handyman takes to his shed to invent stuff. Like a pinecone bag. That being a regular tote bag with a bunch of pinecones affixed to it. Or an egg belt—a leather belt featuring a few pouches in which one puts eggs. Not invented by Brian as such but pointed out by the character to the invisible person operating the camera is his “cabbage bin,” which is a trash bin exclusively for cabbages. Used or new, he doesn’t say. 

You get the idea about the whimsy, yes? A little later Brian shows off a “flying cuckoo clock” which catches fire rather than flies. 

Soon Brian sets about creating a robot because he’s kind of awkward around real people. Using a washing machine for a torso and a mannequin head outfitted with some kind of sensor in the right eye socket, it’s an ungainly creature. Plus it won’t turn on, whatever rudimentary form of artificial intelligence Brian’s outfitted it with. But one night, the invention does come to life—during a thunderstorm, just like Frankenstein’s monster. Soon he is given the name Charles and showing off knowledge he acquires by reading dictionaries overnight. He becomes an expert on cabbages too. (Charles is performed by Chris Hayward, who co-wrote the picture with Earl; the characters originated in a short film from 2017.) 

Brian’s philosophy is simple: “You can try things. You don’t succeed. You just gotta keep trying.” The cumbersome Charles, he admits, was something that aspired to be a “Victorian sponge cake” but instead came out “a blancmange.” That’s okay. Brian likes blancmange, and he likes Charles too. Eventually there’s a montage of them walking together, laughing together, having a pillow fight, and this montage is scored to the classic pop hit by the Turtles, “Happy Together.” It was at this point when I scrawled in my notebook “No. Just no.” 

But again, your mileage may vary. Growth occurs when Charles plays matchmaker for Brian and a shy local (Louise Brealey). Conflict occurs when a clan of rotters, the Toppingtons, kidnap Charles. Leading to a battle of the beardos: Brian’s beard is black and flecked with gray, a kind of melancholy mask, whereas the facial hair of Eddie Toppington (Jamie Michie) is fiery red and warlike. The outcome of course will be determined by who is most ingenious. I’ll award the movie points for novelty, as it’s the only one I’ve seen in which Chekhov’s law about first-act guns is applied to cabbages. 

"Brian and Charles" will be available in theaters on June 17.

Glenn Kenny

Glenn Kenny was the chief film critic of Premiere magazine for almost half of its existence. He has written for a host of other publications and resides in Brooklyn. Read his answers to our Movie Love Questionnaire here.

Now playing

You'll Never Find Me
La Chimera
Dad & Step-Dad
Civil War

Film Credits

Brian and Charles movie poster

Brian and Charles (2022)

Rated PG for language, mild violence, and smoking.

90 minutes


David Earl as Brian

Chris Hayward as Charles

Louise Brealey as Hazel

Jamie Michie as Eddie

Nina Sosanya as Pam

Lynn Hunter as Winnie

Lowri Izzard as Katrina

Mari Izzard as Suki





Latest blog posts


comments powered by Disqus