Maggie can hardly believe her eyes. She has awoken to find a star rating hovering above her head. How it got there and who is behind its sudden appearance are not at the forefront of Maggie’s immediate concerns. What alarms her, above all, is the fact that she has only been granted two and a half stars, while her husband Brian has somehow earned five. 

Such a premise would have seemed purely fantastical a decade ago, but it is horrifyingly plausible in our modern era. It serves as the hook for “Rated,” the directorial feature debut of John Fortson, who stars as Brian and based it off of his award-winning 2016 short film of the same name. Both the short and the feature cast Fortson’s real-life wife and kids, all accomplished actors in their own right, as Brian’s family. 

Christie Lynn Smith delivers a tour de force performance as Maggie, while her children Abby Ryder Fortson (who brilliantly anchored 2023’s “Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret.”) and Joshua Fortson take on the respective roles of teenage daughter Hannah and young son Joshua. Dale Dickey, a recent Emmy-nominee for “Widow’s Bay,” plays Lani, a homeless woman Maggie encounters, while another veteran character actor, Spencer Garrett, appears as Brian’s writing mentor, Jerry.

Prior to the film’s world premiere at the Austin Film Festival, RogerEbert.com spoke with Garrett, Dickey and the entire Fortson family about the timeliness of their picture and the palpable hope that they wish for it to instill in viewers. 

During my first Fortson family interview in 2020, Abby said, “When you’re working with other people, you always have to meet them and get comfortable with them. When you’re with your family, you are already comfortable. You are already home,” to which Christie replied, “That’s so sweet. I hope she feels that way for a very long time.” How does this experience of working together contrast with making the short?

John Fortson (JF): Being able to interact as adults with my cast and my family, there’s already a chemistry and a beautiful air of familiarity between us. There are so many nuances that bubble out of it that I think are just gold. Every day that we would shoot, it was so much fun to be here with my family and live in the scene together. It was like real life, in a way.

Christie Lynn Smith (CS): I also think there’s a level of trust that enables us to play because we know that the other person is going to catch whatever we throw. There is a scene in the car where everyone is overlapping, and it creates a real familial energy. It was just a joy and a blessing for us to work together again. 

To what extent did Abby and Joshua influence the evolution of their characters in the feature?

Abby Ryder Fortson (AF): I was six when we shot the short version of “Rated,” and have been seeing this project through ever since. In the course of getting the feature to fruition, my character has developed many more times. I know for a fact that my character as it was originally written in the feature film is not what you see onscreen because my own experiences, both with my parents and just growing up as a teenager, helped inform the script. One of the great things about the way that the timing worked out was that, with me as a teenager and my mom getting older, there were a lot of parallels in our experiences. We were really able to play with that and, consciously and unconsciously, make that a really interesting side of the film. 

JF: I had originally written the feature script back when Abby was 8 and Joshua was 4. As time went on, I would have to make passes through the script to adjust the ages. What was so fun was we would improvise a scene with Abby and Joshua playing it at the ages they were, and the scene dynamics would change. We’d tape record it and then go back and rewrite the scene. So the script just kept evolving and incorporating new layers until it became what it is today.

CS: A lot of scenes came from improvisation. I remember doing the fight scene with Abby in our dining room, and really going to town, figuring out how she was going to push me and lift me up. I feel like I really broke my heart open. There was so much of my own insecurities that could translate into Maggie and vice versa, since she is an overwhelmed mother of two who is perimenopausal. My scene with Dale Dickey also brought me to a place of vulnerability.  

I feel that your scene with Dale is the heart of the movie. 

Dale Dickey (DD): I have a tough time sometimes watching myself in certain things. My scene in “Rated” was a particularly tough shoot. We did a lot of takes where I began the scene dragging Christie from the street—which was ultimately cut—and I was pretty exhausted by the end of it. Everybody was very patient with me. I knew it was an important character and an important role, and so I think there were times when I was trying too hard. I wanted to make it special, I didn’t want to ruin their film, and that’s the worst thing an actor can do is try too hard. You just have to relax and be there. So I struggled a little bit, but it’s a beautifully written role. 

I was really just there for that one night in Oklahoma, and it was a cold one in November. It was a little stressful because we were filming on the street, and there were a lot of moving parts. I’m sure we were on a time constraint, and at one point, the lines just went. I don’t know what happened—it wasn’t the cold or the tiredness—and that hardly ever happens with me. I remember being so horrified and embarrassed, thinking, ‘I’m the person that should have no stars!’ But John was a calming, sweet, kind presence, assuring me that everything was going to be okay. 

Christie broke my heart in that scene. She was so committed and so real, and I wanted to give her everything that she needed. I was feeling that I wasn’t, and then I beat myself up, as we all do in life. It made me want to make it even better. She just hung in there with me and it ended up being a lovely experience. The Fortsons are a great family!

They remind me of the McKenzie family of actors from New Zealand, whose daughter, Thomasin, you worked with in “Leave No Trace.”

DD: I’ve met that family too! You can tell when kids have had good parenting. We’re all human, we all make mistakes, but kids who grow up grounded with a good sense of themselves in the world are instilled with the knowledge that there are other people besides themselves, that we’re all in this together, and that we’re all equal. They are giving, loving and kind people, and I think that’s a beautiful thing that we need more of in this world.

It’s especially odd interviewing you, Spencer, since you were so memorable as the interviewer in “Once Upon a Time…in Hollywood.” I wanted to watch your conversation with Morey Amsterdam and Rose Marie that your character, Alan Kincaid, teases at the end of his scene. 

Spencer Garrett (SG): I actually came up with that line. Quentin said, “This scene needs a button, but I didn’t write it. Could you come up with something?”, and I said, “Yeah, sure, two-time Oscar-winner Quentin Tarantino, I’d be happy to.” He told me to just think of TV actors in the 60s, riff on it and do a little sign-off. I asked Quentin, “Do you know who my mom is?”, and he said, “Yeah, she’s Kathy Nolan who was on ‘The Real McCoys.’” So I did three different sign-offs as Alan Kincaid, and the first one I said was, “Join us next week on the set of ‘The Real McCoys’ where I interview that beautiful and talented redhead, Kathy Nolan. This is Alan Kincaid from Hollywood!” On the second take, I mentioned Morey Amsterdam and Rose Marie, and on the last, I think I went with Phil Silvers. 

I was really excited because I thought the sign-off homaging my mother would be the one that Quentin would use. But at the premiere, he came up to me and said, “I couldn’t use that one because ‘The Real McCoys’ predated ‘Bounty Law’ by six years.” I said, “You killed Hitler! You kept Sharon Tate alive! You couldn’t fuck with the space-time continuum a little bit for my mother?” [laughs] My father was a talent agent and he represented Morey Amsterdam. My mother was Wendy in the Broadway production of Peter Pan with Mary Martin, and she did the live television version in the 50s. She’s still a working actor and just turned 93 in September. Last spring, she got to see me make my Broadway debut in Dog Day Afternoon with Jon Bernthal. It was a great moment for our family. I’m a third generation actor, and I’m trying to keep my family tree alive in the business.

When I saw the short film of “Rated” during the COVID-19 pandemic, empathy was literally saving lives by causing us to be mindful of others. How could we have predicted that the feature version of “Rated” would premiere at a time when the richest man on earth has deemed empathy an enemy, while enabling unregulated technology to further monitor and divide us? As funny and touching as this film is, it also feels like its premise could happen tomorrow, which is terrifying. 

DD: Everything you’ve just said is so perfect. There are so many themes running through this, but what stands out in today’s world are the forces that are trying to make us conform and ruin our individuality and humanness. It’s really scary. 

SG: The fact that people are agreeing with this sentiment because of the god-like stature that this trillionaire has right now is just bananas to me. He has such sway over our lives, and when he makes a comment like that, I’m like, “How have we gotten here where empathy is a pejorative?” The culture sees that and embraces that, and that’s how you have 18-year-old guys signing up for ICE and macing people in the street. So it’s a strange new world. I’m trying to be hopeful that we’re going to find our way out of this somehow, and not end up in “Terminator 2.”

JF: What has been going on in America and the rest of the world could not be ignored in the script. The film speaks to how we treat each other in our society, and how obsessed we are with receiving “likes” on our phone. When the short came out, it was on the cusp of everyone asking, “What is Instagram? Should I be on it?”

DD: When John asked me to be in the feature, I watched the short and found that I couldn’t stop thinking about it. It made me think, “My god, I’m so snappy and rude sometimes just because I’m in a bad mood or there’s been traffic.” I’ve been in the service industry, and now I feel like I have to go back and apologize for my behavior. 

CS: What’s crazy is we shot the feature in 2024, and there is a scene in it that takes place at a detention center. This was before ICE was heavily in the news. It gives me chills that people can just scan our face and know anything about us, including how many children that we have. “Rated” was timely ten years ago, but now it is going to resonate on an even deeper level.

SG: John is an old friend, and that’s how the project came to me. The germ of his idea for “Rated” came from how Uber drivers can rate their customers sitting in the back of their car, which is just bizarre to me. I think we are going down a very slippery slope by judging people based on how you perceive them in the moment. 

AF: I just started college, and I looked up one of my professors who is maybe not my favorite on the website RateMyProfessors.com, and found that he has not the best rating on it. I’ve talked to other students where I go, and they’ve been picking classes based off of the ratings that they see on this site. I’ve read through a couple just for my own interest, and some of them are totally valid. But then others say something like, “I interacted with this person once, and they were in a bad mood.” 

Even through something as niche as a rating system for professors in college, I think it is very, very interesting how we are almost trained by the internet nowadays to make assumptions about people based on a rating on Yelp or Google or Rate My Professors. So yes, our film is incredibly pertinent and incredibly timely, and I think unfortunately, it will only get even more relevant and important as we move forward with technological advancements that are based on surveillance and reducing people to their actions in a negative way.

JF: I really think that as we all go through life, we’re formed as people through the things that don’t work out. By choosing things according to their star rating, everything becomes a smoother experience instead of building up through a lifetime of ups and downs. People only want the ups. What kind of character does that build?’

CS: I miss the day when you could just go somewhere, find a restaurant, and you would like it or not like it based on your own experience. If we all woke up tomorrow with star ratings over our heads, my fear is that we would lose authenticity. We would all try to strive for five stars so much that we would become robots, instead of being our authentic selves having a bad day. You could’ve lost your pet, you could’ve lost your job, you could’ve gotten in a car accident, you could just be sick. As human beings, we are so sensitive to everyone not being perfect to us that we automatically judge them. But what if, instead, we just came up to them and asked, “Hey, is everything okay? Is something going on?” 

I wear my heart on my sleeve as Christie anyway, but I think Maggie doesn’t really do that. She just bottles it up and takes it out on others because that is either how she has grown up or what she has learned. But there eventually becomes a softness to Maggie when she realizes that it’s okay, we’re all doing our best, and we are all enough. She goes from a place of selfishness to selflessness in the end by fighting for everybody. If we could all give a little more to others, it would help our dynamic with the world and all of its inhabitants. 

SG: Christie’s performance as Maggie is astonishing. I watched the film yesterday for the first time, and I’m just so impressed with what they’ve done. My role of Jerry is hilarious, and reminds me of the character that Bryan Cranston played in “Little Miss Sunshine.” He’s the guy who can kind of maybe make it happen for Brian with his book about sustainable marriages, and suddenly he says, “Oh yeah, I’m not going to do that after all. I’m getting divorced and I’m completely flipping the script.” 

John and I had a lot of fun playing around that table in the coffee shop. It was important that, as with all my roles, I didn’t judge Jerry. I’ve played many guys, such as Tom DeLay and Sean Hannity, who have a twisted moral core and are easy to judge. Jerry just wants to live his own life and have fun. I adore John as a person, as a father, as a family man, and now as a director. He’s made something really special, and I’m really proud to be a part of it. 

The takeaway for me in this film is don’t judge somebody based on what you’re just seeing right in front of you, because you never know what they are struggling with behind the scenes. John has taken that concept to a whole other level because we are now in this world where phones and Flock cameras are spying on people’s lives. The film is a dramedy, but there’s also a little bit of a horror element to it.

It’s interesting that this film is a comedy, since its story could easily be approached as straight horror. Yet the comedy somehow makes the subject matter more impactful.

DD: John just sent me a link to the film, and I watched it early this morning. I was just thrilled by the comedy and the music, which is almost madcap. It puts you in the space that we are all in, and it is important for us to be able to laugh at ourselves. Thank god for the comedians who are out there keeping us sane every night by telling the truth and giving us some humor to get through these very difficult, traumatic times that our country is enduring. Laughter is key. I’m still learning how to just let things roll off and not take myself so seriously.

JF: What I like about the film is that it offers choices. We feel for people in our society who are trapped by the trappings of their life, who remain in a job even if they feel morally challenged by it, such as the characters we see working at the detention center. Then you see people who stand up and say, “You know what? Whatever the consequences, we don’t have to do this anymore. We can come together and treat people right. Forget about these rules that we’ve made up for this rock we are occupying in outer space!” Our core value of kindness—opening a door for someone—is the simplest thing, and I think “Rated” gives us an opportunity to shine a light on it.

DD: This screening marks my second time in Austin. I came to SXSW for literally 24 hours with a movie called “Small Town Crime” by the Nelms brothers. It starred Octavia Spencer and John Hawkes, and I came out with a shotgun—my usual self, “salty bartender.” [laughs] I was in and out, and didn’t get to experience the festival. I’ve heard that the Austin Film Festival is more focused on writing and the artistic side of film rather than huge marketability. I’m really looking forward to attending the premiere tonight. 

With John and Christie both making their directorial efforts—Christie with her short film, “Everyone Has Issues…”, which brought down the house during its world premiere at the Cinema Femme Short Film Festival in Chicago last month—is this a path Abby and Joshua are interested in exploring as well? 

Joshua Fortson (JS): Yeah, I applied to high school for film andI want to get behind the camera and direct.

CS: His school has a filmmaking program where he’ll actually be making his own movies. I’m so proud!

AF: I am very, very interested in directing. I’ve been writing for a long time and have finished multiple features. Nothing has come of them yet, but I would love to direct and continue to write. One of my main goals in the future is to start an A24-like production company.

JF: I could not be happier with my family wanting to be in the arts. At the core of it, it is a mirror to our world in which we can share what impacts us, what enriches us, what ignites us and inspires us.  It is a beautiful place for self-reflection, and I am super-proud of these guys.

CS: And we want to keep making movies together. We have a couple things in development right now, so we are hopeful!

Matt Fagerholm

Matt Fagerholm is the former Literary Editor at RogerEbert.com and is a member of the Chicago Film Critics Association.

 

Leave a comment

subscribe icon

The best movie reviews, in your inbox