Alice Through the Looking Glass
There is no magic, no wonder, just junk rehashed from a movie that was itself a rehash of Lewis Carroll, tricked out with physically unpersuasive…
Typically, the cinematographer is the director’s right hand man, a vital, top tier player in the filmmaking process. The cinematographer not only is the expert of lighting design and acts as head of the camera and electrical department, he or she is also the trademark artistic visual voice of a film. For example, it’s hard to imagine an Alfonso Cuarón film without the free-flowing, single-take prowess of cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki. Or try to picture a Wong Kar-wai movie without the pulsating color schemes and palettes composed by moving image impresario Christopher Doyle. These are moving image creators, who have each branded trademark styles from their ubiquitous collaborations with certain directors. These directors owe much of their success—and more importantly their titles of being hailed as “auteurs”—to their cinematographers. Director Bong Joon-ho is a special case: his films are largely credited to his own uncompromising visual style, as opposed to his cinematographers.
One only has to look at Bong’s five feature films to see that it is the director’s image-making trademark that is in full force. Beginning with his "Barking Dogs Never Bite," where Bong worked with two cinematographers (Yong-kyou Cho and Yeong-gyu Jo), the visual scheme was quickly etched into place: an energetically-infused batch of kinetic, profile-framing handheld shots mixed with pensive, long takes that zero in an emotion or action. There’s a quiet, entrancing scene in "Barking" where the camera observes a roll of toilet paper unfurl down a street with as much seriousness as another shot in the film of blood trickling down a character’s nose.
When Bong moved on to create "Memories of Murder" and the much-adored monster film "The Host," he tapped cinematographer Kim Hyung-ku to serve as the director of photography. But hardly anything new was added by Kim, in terms of idea innovation; it was still Bong’s canvas and Kim’s role was to take the visual rhythms and emotions that were already set from "Barking" to higher technical heights.
An early scene in "The Host," which features a monster attacking civilians on land, is one of the most memorable set pieces of the 2000s. Again, using an unusual framing strategy (tracking shots that zoom in and out, while keeping characters in profile) coupled with more traditional “long take” shots, the sequence was all the more enthralling because the clarity of the images in motion were spelled out to a consistent “visual music.” (Contrast this to the indecipherable, headache-inducing image destruction found in a Michael Bay film.) Bong at this point cemented himself as the invisible cinematographer of his own films, in a sense.
With "Mother" and the recently released "Snowpiercer," Bong has already tapped his fourth cinematographer (Hong Kyung-pyo) in only five feature films. Usually that’s a recipe for a disastrous, sporadic visual style in one’s filmography but for Bong, it’s further proof that he is one of the few, true working directors who actually deserves the title of “visionary.” What you’re seeing in those frames, on that screen, is thrillingly alive and wholly his.
This message came to me from a reader named Peter Svensland. He and a fr...
Separating the artist from the art isn't as easy as it sounds.
Part two of Jana Monji's essay about the portrayal of Asian characters in cinema.