The fact that he doesn’t try to redeem these flawed, fascinating figures—or even try to make you like them in the slightest way—feels like an…
"Okay, the Superhero genre is boring. So let's make better superhero movies": The Stake's Christopher Finke responds to Matt Zoller Seitz's editorial "Things Crashing Into Other Things: Or, My Superhero Movie Problem." Related: Two writers at The Atlantic offer their own responses to Seitz's piece: Tim Wainwright and Derek Thompson.
"Zoller Seitz hits the genre (and its fans) the hardest, but also with the most accurate shots. Yes, the action scenes are often incomprehensible; acting talent often comes second to looking the part; fans do hold on to 'fleeting moments of special-ness' to defend a films that are, as a whole, mediocre. But the problem with all of these genre assessments is that they are just that: high-level assessments of a genre. What this level of analysis forgets (though Wainwright hits on the point) is that a large majority of everything is low-quality. Whatever genre you’re considering, it’s probably on average pretty terrible. Because most movies, just like most television and most books, are terrible. Popular appetites and risk-averse business decisions have something to do with this general mediocrity, but not everything. Some of it also comes from the fact that making quality films is really difficult. Levelize the quality of any genre and you’ll find mediocrity at best."
"Pamphlet for Activist Film Criticism": Members of the German Film Critic's Association have released and signed an official statement, written in honor of Critics' Week at the Berlin International Film Festival, declaring that they will "no longer accept the abuse of film criticism as service" (scroll to the bottom of the linked page for the English translation).
“Criticism itself faces a drastic dilemma. To articulate itself, it needs to adapt its thinking to the norms and conditions of contemporary markets. During this process, it trades in its sovereignty and becomes service. Independent thinking is replaced by reflex. Those who turn in free thinking lose the capability of questioning the establishment. Frameworks are declared as determinants. Visions are abandoned. The lack of economic perspectives must no longer lead to intellectual assimilation. Those who turn in free thinking subject themselves to consensus and compromise. A productive culture of debate becomes impossible. But controversy and debate are essential for the unfolding of vivid discourse. Without discourse, there is no culture. Without discourse, there is no knowledge. In fact, ignorance is fostered.”
"'Searching for Sugar Man''s Oscar-Winning Director Dead at 36": Vanity Fair's Julie Miller reports on the tragic death of documentary filmmaker Malik Bendjelloul.
“‘Searching for Sugar Man’’s subject Sixto Rodriguez, the fabled folk singer whom Malik set out to find in his wonderfully moving documentary, performed a concert on Tuesday night in Detroit. Afterward, he spoke to Billboard, revealing that the news of Bendjelloul’s death was ‘a shock.’ ‘I just found out about it a couple of hours ago. He was a very talented man and hard-working artist—he proved it by hitting an Academy Award his first time out. My deepest condolences to his family. Rest in peace.’”
"Fat woman talking: 'Louie' starts a necessary conversation": Libby Hill writes an excellent piece for The A.V. Club on how Louis C.K. "has given voice to the fat girl." See also: Hill's recent article for RogerEbert.com, "In Defense of Norma Bates or How 'Bates Motel' Radically Reinvents 'Psycho.'"
“Fat is a dirty word. It’s an admonishment and a death sentence, especially in the world of dating, and even more so in the world of pop culture. But being fat is not a burden that weighs on everyone equally. It’s no accident that ‘So Did The Fat Lady’ falls in episode order directly after ‘Model,’ an episode featuring Louie improbably hooking up with a young blonde woman (played by Yvonne Strahovski). The question both episodes ask is: What cost are we willing to pay for a relationship? (Even one that lasts only a night?) In ‘Model,’ the price Louie pays for a completely unexpected night of passion with a beautiful model is astronomical, at least financially. No matter how unintentionally, it saddles him with a debt he’ll pay the rest of his life, and yet, by the end, he’s fine with it and moves on to greener pastures. In ‘So Did The Fat Lady,’ however, he encounters a price he is unwilling to pay. For him, the perceived cost of holding a fat woman’s hand in public is petrifying because of the horror that being with Vanessa may be where he belongs. The model may have cost him his dignity and his money, but the fat lady would cost him his manhood.”
"Why Jill Abramson Was Fired": The New Yorker's Ken Auletta makes his case for why the New York Times's first female executive editor in its 160-year history was fired after less than three years on the job. Related: New Republic's Rebecca Traister tries to explain the "humiliating firing" with her piece, "I Sort Of Hope We Find Out That Jill Abramson Was Robbing the Cash Register." See also: The Guardian reports that Natalie Nougayrède, editor of the French newspaper, Le Monde, has quit after enduring "personal and direct attacks."
“As with any such upheaval, there’s a history behind it. Several weeks ago, I’m told, Abramson discovered that her pay and her pension benefits as both executive editor and, before that, as managing editor were considerably less than the pay and pension benefits of Bill Keller, the male editor whom she replaced in both jobs. ‘She confronted the top brass,’ one close associate said, and this may have fed into the management’s narrative that she was ‘pushy,’ a characterization that, for many, has an inescapably gendered aspect. Sulzberger is known to believe that the ‘Times,’ as a financially beleaguered newspaper, needed to retreat on some of its generous pay and pension benefits; Abramson had also been at the ‘Times’ for far fewer years than Keller, having spent much of her career at the ‘Wall Street Journal,’ accounting for some of the pension disparity. Eileen Murphy, a spokeswoman for the ‘Times,’ said that Jill Abramson’s total compensation as executive editor ‘was directly comparable to Bill Keller’s’—though it was not actually the same.”
Stephen Dowling of the BBC pens a wonderfully optimistic piece about "why filmmakers may return to old-school special effects." Gavin Rothery, a special effects supervisor on "Moon," also gets in a nice dig at the "Transformers" franchise, dubbing it "high frequency noise."
In today's edition of the "Carvajal Corner," editor extraordinaire Nelson Carvajal presents his latest video essay visualizing the words of writer Jed Mayer. Mayer's essay "juxtaposes dwindling species of certain animals against their digital counterparts on screen, which seem to grow exponentially, year after year."
A comparison of Frank Costello in The Departed and Whitey Bulger in Black Mass reveals weaknesses in the latter.
A NYFF report on new films from Chantal Akerman and Michel Gondry.
This message came to me from a reader named Peter Svensland. He and a fr...
Our monthly series digs into the career of Wes Craven and comes out with his 3D 2010 film, "My Soul to Take".