The abiding terror in Alfred Hitchcock's life was that he would
be accused of a crime he did not commit. This fear is at the heart of many of
his best films, including "Strangers on a Train" (1951), in which a
man becomes the obvious suspect in the strangulation of his wife. He makes an
excellent suspect because of the genius of the actual killer's original plan:
Two strangers will "exchange murders," each killing the person the other
wants dead. They would both have airtight alibis for the time of the crime, and
there would be no possible connection between killer and victim.
is a plot made of ingenuity and amorality, based on the first novel by Patricia
Highsmith (1921-1995), who in her Ripley novels and elsewhere was fascinated by
brainy criminals who functioned not out of passion but from careful
calculation, and usually got away with their crimes. The
"criss-cross" murder deal in "Strangers on a Train" indeed
would have worked perfectly -- except for the detail that only one of the
strangers agrees to it.
Haines, a famous tennis player, is recognized on a train by Bruno Anthony,
whose conversation shows a detailed knowledge of Guy's private life. Guy wants
a divorce from his cheating wife, Miriam (Kasey Rogers), in order to marry Anne
Morton (Ruth Roman), the daughter of a U.S. senator. Over lunch in his private
compartment, Bruno reveals that he wants his father dead, and suggests a
"perfect crime" in which he would murder Guy's wife, Guy would murder
Bruno's father, and neither would ever be suspected.
manner is pushy and insinuating, with homoerotic undertones. Guy is offended by
the references to his private life, but inexplicably doesn't break off the
conversation -- which ends on an ambiguous note, with Bruno trying to get Guy
to agree to the plan, and Guy trying to jolly him along and get rid of him.
Bruno does murder Guy's wife, and then demands that Guy keep his half of the
bargain. As a plot, this has a neatness that Hitchcock must have found
irresistible -- especially since Guy has a motive to murder his wife, was seen
in a public fight with her earlier on the day of her death, and even told his fiancée
he would like to "strangle" Miriam.
said that correct casting saved him a reel in storytelling time, since
audiences would sense qualities in the actors that didn't need to be spelled
out. Certainly the casting of Farley Granger as Guy and Robert Walker as Bruno
is crucial. Hitchcock allegedly wanted William Holden for the role of Guy
("he's stronger," he told Francois Truffaut), but Holden would have
been all wrong -- too sturdy, too put off by Bruno (despite the way Holden
allowed an aging actress to manipulate him in "Sunset Boulevard").
is softer and more elusive, more convincing as he tries to slip out of Bruno's
conversational web instead of flatly rejecting him. Walker plays Bruno as
flirtatious and seductive, sitting too close during their first meeting, and
then reclining at full length across from Guy in the private compartment. The
meeting on the train, which was probably planned by Bruno, plays more like a
pickup than a chance encounter.
is this sense of two flawed characters -- one evil, one weak, with an unstated
sexual tension -- that makes the movie intriguing and halfway plausible, and
helps explain how Bruno could come so close to carrying out his plan. Highsmith
was a lesbian whose novels have uncanny psychological depth; Andrew Wilson's
2003 biography says she often fell in love with straight women, and her stories
frequently use a buried subtext of unstated gay attraction -- as in "The
Talented Mr. Ripley," made into a 1999 movie in which her criminal hero
Tom Ripley falls in love not so much with his quarry Dickie Greenleaf as with
his identity and lifestyle.
homosexuality still dared not speak its name very loudly in 1951, Hitchcock was
quite aware of Bruno's orientation, and indeed edited separate American and
British version of the film -- cutting down the intensity of the
"seductiveness" in the American print. It's worth noticing that
Hitchcock also cast Granger in "Rope" (1948), based on the
Leopold-Loeb case; it was another story about a murder pact with a homosexual
on a Train" is not a psychological study, however, but a first-rate
thriller with odd little kinks now and then. It proceeds, as Hitchcock's films
so often do, with a sense of private scores being settled just out of sight.
His obsession with being wrongly accused no doubt refers to a traumatic episode
in his childhood, when his father sent naughty little Alfred to the police
station with a note asking the sergeant to lock him up until called for.
Interesting, in this context, is Hitchcock's casting of his own daughter,
Patricia, as the outspoken young Barbara Morton, kid sister of Guy's fiancée
Anne. Patricia Hitchcock and Kasey Rogers look a little alike and wear very
similar eyeglasses; Bruno is playfully demonstrating strangling techniques at a
party when he sees Barbara, flashes back to the murder, and flips out. The kid
sister gets the creepiest lines in "Strangers on a Train," especially
during an early meeting involving Guy and the senator's whole family; she keeps
blurting out what everyone is afraid to say.
was above all the master of great visual set pieces, and there are several
famous sequences in "Strangers on a Train." Best known is the one
where Guy scans the crowd at a tennis match and observes that all of the heads
are swiveling back and forth to follow the game -- except for one head,
Bruno's, which is looking straight ahead at Guy. (The same technique was used
in Hitchcock's "Foreign Correspondent," where all the windmills
rotate in the same direction -- except one.)
effective scene shows Guy floating in a little boat through the Tunnel of Love
at a carnival; Miriam and two boyfriends are in the boat ahead, and shadows on
the wall make it appear Bruno has overtaken them. In a scene where Guy goes
upstairs in the dark in Bruno's house, Hitchcock told Truffaut, he hit on the
inspiration of a very large dog to distract the audience from what he would
probably find at the top.
there's the famous sequence involving a runaway merry-go-round, on which Guy
and Bruno struggle as a carnival worker crawls on his stomach under the
revolving ride to get to the controls. (This shot was famously unfaked, and the
stunt man could have been killed; Hitchcock said he would never take such a
chance again.) Another great shot shows Bruno's face in the shadow of his hat brim,
only the whites of his eyes showing.
was a classical technician in controlling his visuals, and his use of screen
space underlined the tension in ways the audience is not always aware of. He
always used the convention that the left side of the screen is for evil and/or
weaker characters, while the right is for characters who are either good, or
temporarily dominant. Consider the scene where Guy is letting himself into his
Georgetown house when Bruno whispers from across the street to summon him.
Bruno is standing behind an iron gate, the bars casting symbolic shadows on his
face, and Guy stands to his right, outside the gate. Then a police car pulls up
in front of Guy's house, and he quickly moves behind the gate with Bruno;
they're now both behind bars as he says, "You've got me acting like I'm a
Robert Walker performance benefits from a subtle tense urgency that perhaps
reflected events in his private life; he had a nervous breakdown shortly after
filming was completed, was institutionalized for treatment, and died of an
accidental overdose of tranquilizers. (Leftover closeups from this film were
used to finish his final film, "My Son John.") Although Hitchcock
said in Francois Truffaut's book-length interview that he didn't much like
either of the actors, Walker's Bruno has been called one of Hitchcock's best
villains, and Hitch agreed with Truffaut that the audience sympathy was more
with him than with Granger's playboy.
movie is usually ranked among Hitchcock's best (I would put it below only
"Vertigo," "Notorious," "Psycho" and perhaps
"Shadow of a Doubt"), and its appeal is probably the linking of an
ingenious plot with insinuating creepiness. That combination came in the first
place from Highsmith, whose novels have been unfairly shelved with crime
fiction when she actually writes mainstream fiction about criminals.
an intriguing note from a user of the Internet Movie Database, claiming to have
spotted Highsmith in a cameo in the film. She's behind Miriam in the early
scene in the record store, writing something in a notebook. No Highsmith cameo
has even been reported in the movie's lore (all the attention goes to
Hitchcock's trademark cameo) but you can look for yourself, in chapter six of
the DVD, 12 minutes and 16 seconds into the running time. To think she may have
been haunting it all of these years.