Roger Ebert Home

Hulu’s Life & Beth is a Heartfelt Mixed Bag

A 40-ish woman, deeply unsatisfied with her life and over-reliant on alcohol, returns to her hometown in the wake of a family tragedy. Reconnecting with old acquaintances from her youth, she faces old wounds from her past, including a fraught relationship with her mother, returns an old passion from her teenage days, and takes steps towards reconnecting with her sister as she seeks to rediscover a sense of joy and meaning in life. These statements describe “Somebody, Somewhere,” the remarkably touching HBO dramedy starring and executive produced by Bridget Everett that premiered back in January, and now they also apply to “Life & Beth,” the new Hulu series created, written, and directed by Amy Schumer, a long-time friend and repeat collaborator of Everett’s. One wonders if the two ever discussed these projects while in development, and if so, how those conversations might have gone, because just watching the end results overlap feels quite uncanny. 

However, the more episodes that go by, the more Schumer’s series differentiates itself. While Sam of “Somebody Somewhere” finds herself in her small hometown having failed to make any lasting mark in New York, in a soul-crushing dead-end job, “Life & Beth” sees the titular protagonist in circumstances that sound quite idyllic—in a long-term relationship with a “New York eight,” excelling in her job as a wine sales representative and up for a significant promotion—but deeply unhappy anyway. Boyfriend Matt (a delightfully detestable Kevin Kane) is a human disaster barely held together with duct tape who, after the better part of a decade, only proposes marriage at the worst possible moment with the terrible but also terribly funny, “we’re finally getting married, ring TBD” (just the romantic proposal ever girl dreams of). The seemingly well-suited job soon reveals itself as unsatisfying, and a convenient excuse to drink regularly in excess while actively ignoring that she has a problem at all.  

The obvious parallels to Schumer’s actual childhood and personal life are numerous, and central enough that going into too much detail here would feel like giving the whole series away. The most compelling aspects of “Life & Beth” undoubtedly come from its raw honesty and the connection to Schumer’s own life, but the show’s shortcomings feel similarly rooted in just how close the creator is to the material; having such a close perspective often has distortive effects, and this series suffers from a lack of focus particularly common among such autobiographical tales. The particular combination of elements that comprise Beth’s story are easiest to comprehend in the context of Schumer’s own, which feels nearly prerequisite to this series. 

Somewhat ironically, the lack of focus here is ultimately easier to forgive because many of the show’s strongest moments come from when it diverges from its intent. While ultimately “Life & Beth” aims to zero in on Beth’s fraught relationship with her mother Jane (Laura Benanti), primarily explored through extended flashbacks featuring Violet Young as a young teenage Beth dealing with the collapse of her parents’ marriage following the failure of her father’s business, Beth’s relationship with Jane is far from the most compelling in the series. 

“No one loves you like your mom, and no one hurts you like your mom,” Beth reflects to a captive audience late in the season with the gravity that clearly points to an intended thesis statement. However, as much as Jane sparks the series’ inciting incident and effectively functions as a major obstacle for Beth to overcome, she never feels rendered with the same sort of graspable humanity that imbues the other major characters, despite an earnest performance from Berlanti. 

While Jane often drives the action, she feels at once too plot-convenient and emotionally opaque to strike a resonant cord; Beth’s connection to her ne’er do well father Leonard (Michael Rapaport) is ironically, and in a way that definitely feels unintentional, the far more effectively rendered parental relationship. The series hints and gradually builds their connection, effectively setting up a complicated bond that pays off in “Leonard,” one of the most emotionally effective and resonant episodes of the series overall.  While that old saying “show don’t tell” isn’t always entirely true, the impact Leonard has on Beth and what she learns from him—from her sales skills to her alcoholism—feels organically built into the series in a way that the much more heavy-handed but ultimately less effective efforts to explore Beth’s relationship with Jane never accomplish. With a central relationship that never lands quite as impactfully as it clearly means to, the show’s extensive detours into other territory are actually quite welcome, as they often traverse far more compelling landscapes. 

“Life & Beth” is the sort of show that, if anything, features a surplus of talent, with brilliant comedians filling even the smallest and blandest of roles (the pilot in particular makes an unfortunate waste of Janelle James). Yamaneika Saunders shines as Kiana, a childhood friend of Beth’s whom she reconnects with upon returning to Long Island, a character that on occasion toes the line of a stereotypical sassy Black friend role but is overall handled with a respectably deft hand. Susannah Flood is similarly mesmerizing as Beth’s enigmatic sister Ann. Of the more minor players, Jonathan Groff is a remarkable as Travis, a small-town big fish who loves “New York” in the most cringe-inducingly painful way only a tourist can. 

While it’s a crowded field, Michael Cera as John, an organic farmer with more than a few surface similarities to Schumer’s real-life husband, stands out as a particularly clever casting choice. John feels like the grown-up version of the endearingly earnest unlikely romantic leads from “Juno” to “Scott Pilgrim vs. the World” that defined Cera’s early career, realistically flawed yet in the present context, his honest-to-a-fault tendencies also feel like something of a romantic fantasy. 

Overall, “Life & Beth” is a mixed bag but ultimately watchable first season. It's a commendably heartfelt passion project from Schumer that introduces enough lovable characters to be engaging, even if it has not quite figured out what to do with half of them quite yet. 

Ten episodes screened for review. The first season of “Life & Beth” premieres on Hulu on March 18. 

Ciara Wardlow

Ciara Wardlow is a freelance writer and development coordinator at the production company Maven Screen Media.

Latest blog posts

Latest reviews

Angelyne
Montana Story
The Essex Serpent
Firestarter
On the Count of Three
Pleasure

Comments

comments powered by Disqus