“What kind of movie is this? Where could it possibly be
Normally, if you find yourself asking such questions, say, a
half-hour into a movie, it’s a sign of one of two possible things. Either the
film is a hopeless, unfocused muddle that doesn’t know what it’s up to. Or it’s
purposefully oblique, taking us on a journey to new and unexpected cinematic
Happily, Karim Aïnouz’s “Futuro Beach” is a prime example of
the latter. And in this case, the unusual artistic itinerary is mirrored by a
significant geographic-cultural one.
The tale begins on the eponymous Brazilian beach, a stretch
of brilliantly white sand, except that in the film’s first minutes our gaze is
drawn away from it and under the ocean’s waves, where bodies are flailing in a
way that makes desperation seem almost balletic. Two men are threatened with
drowning, and one doesn’t return from the sea.
One of the rescuers, Donato (Wagner Moura), is an
ordinary-seeming twentysomething who has an ailing mother and a younger
brother, Ayrton (Savio Ygor Ramos), age ten, who worships him to the point of
dubbing him a superhero—Aquaman. A day or so after the apparent drowning,
Donato is in his office when the lost man’s pal drops by to discuss the
situation. Konrad (Clemens Schick) is a German, a rough-hewn veteran of the
Afghanistan war. He and his friend had been on a journey down to South America,
aiming eventually to return to the motorcycle repair shop they own in Berlin.
Donato explains that the attempt to find the body will continue. Once the
meeting concludes, he offers Konrad a ride back to his hotel.
Cut to: the two men in a torrid sexual encounter,
sweat-soaked, the German aggressively thrusting into his gasping partner.
Though this scene arrives only a few minutes into the story, perhaps it’s fair
to ask: Can we now type what we’re watching as a gay film, though one that,
given its manner, might also be considered an art film?
Perhaps, but it’s remarkable how little this tells us about
the characters, what the film is up to or where’s it’s headed. In another good
example of the gay/art blend, Alain Guiraudie’s “Stranger by the Lake,” we
sense from fairly early on that it’s a Hitchockian thriller with certain
readily identifiable gay types caught up in the drama. Here there are no such
convenient genre or character markers. Moreover, everything is conveyed with
maximum obliqueness. In the scene in Donato’s office, for example, there are
hints of what will happen next, but they are so subtle that they perhaps can be
recognized only in retrospect.
Everything that follows is equally circumspect. The search
for Konrad’s friend continues, and one night he and Donato go down to the pounding
surf to see if it has washed up on the rocks. Konrad talks about continuing his
trek southward and returning when the body is found. What’s just below the
surface here is just the opposite of what’s being said: Konrad doesn’t really
want to leave Donato, who also isn’t eager to part.
We understand this when the second of the film’s three parts
begins. The two men are now living in Berlin, where Konrad is teaching Donato
the language. Konrad has returned to his other passion, motorcycles, and takes
long rides at night by himself. How do the two men feel about each, as the days
turn into months? It’s hard to tell; they are working class guys who obviously
aren’t in the habit of verbalizing their feelings. Indeed, it’s easier to get a
sense of their relationship from watching them dance in a disco than from
anything they say.
Eventually, though, it’s clear that Donato is depressed by
the grayness of Berlin. “I can’t live in a place without a beach,” he says. He
announces his intention to return to Brazil, buys a ticket and makes all the
necessary preparations. Konrad accompanies him on the train to the airport. But
when the train reaches the airport stop, Donato doesn’t get off.
Ultimately, “Futuro Beach” is a film about displacement and
identity, love and its costs. Its considerable satisfactions, though, come
mainly from the way the story is told, which spells nothing out, and in fact is
so reticent that the viewer is constantly drawn into the creation of meaning.
This is a poetic approach, to be sure, but it is entirely nonchalant and
unstudied; and it extends to the understated beauty of the visuals, where the
contrast between the bright colors of Brazil and muted hues of Berlin is its
Aïnouz, who was born in Brazil and now lives in Berlin, has
said that Fassbinder’s “Ali: Fear Eats the Soul” was in his mind when making
this film. I was reminded more of early films by Wim Wenders such as “Alice in
the Cities,” as well as Fatih Akin’s “Head On,” another great movie about
immigrants in present-day Germany. As such comparisons suggest, Aïnouz is now
in a great place: the company of masters.