There are two movies in "Jackie." One of these movies is just OK. The other is exceptional. The first one keeps undermining the second.
High school teachers seem locked in time to us; we seem like part of a flowing stream to them. My teachers are frozen in the late 1950s, an innocent time when high school portals had quotations from Milton carved over the doorways, and no metal detectors. But to them, the Class of 1960 was one of 10, 20, 30 or more classes passing through their hands, and even though Coach Smith did assure us at our 10th reunion that "there was never another class like you," we had the suspicion that he said that at all the reunions.
Holland's Opus" tells the story of 30 years in the life of a high school
music teacher named Glenn Holland, who takes the job in the first place as a
temporary measure. His real work, he believes, is to compose music. Teaching is
just a way to pay some bills. He realizes only gradually that it is, in fact,
his destiny. (Like they say, "What you're doing instead of your real jobISyour real
As the movie opens, Holland (Richard Dreyfuss) and his wife Iris (Glenne Headly) are a couple fueled by his heady ambitions. He will be a great composer, of that he is sure, but then hard financial realities make him take the teaching job, where the hard-edged principal (Olympia Dukakis) looks him over sternly and reads him as a man for whom teaching has no seriousness.
God knows the school needs a music teacher. At his first meeting
with the high school orchestra, he finds they play badly. How badly? I didn't
recognize the first four notes of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony.
(By the end of the film, a successor to this orchestra has so improved that it sounds for all the world like a Hollywood recording stage filled with professional session musicians under the baton of Michael Kamen.)
Meanwhile, the Hollands have a baby, to Iris's delight and
somewhat more muted pleasure -- which turns to coldness when he discovers his son, named Cole, is deaf. Holland almost takes it as a personal affront that his son will not be able to hear the great opus that he still clings to as his ultimate vision.
Year follows year, and it is one of the pleasures of "Mr. Holland's Opus," like "Forrest Gump," that the characters live through many of the watershed events of three decades: The assassination of Kennedy, the war in Vietnam, the plague of drugs and school violence, and the cost-cutting measures that eventually eliminate programs like Mr. Holland's music classes. (The day American high schools admit that "electives" like music, art, and drama are as important as sports will be the day they value culture as much as entertainment for the alums.)
teacher has his favorite students, and Mr. Holland has several. One is a
hopelessly untalented band member (Alicia Witt). Mr. Holland is not able to
make her talented, but he is able to restore her self-esteem, and she reappears
many years later as a woman who learned much more than music in his class.
Another is a beautiful and talented student (Jean Louisa Kelly), who has her
sights set on
show biz, and who falls in love with Mr. Holland, who must walk a delicate emotional tightrope with an end not always in sight.
Although much of the movie involves Mr. Holland helping his students to mature, the character of the son, Cole, provides acounterpoint: A way for Mr. Holland to grow up, too, and accept bothhis son and his life. Some of them scenes between them are painful, and a later scene, where Mr. Holland sings John Lennon's "Beautiful Boy" to Cole, is very moving.
Richard Dreyfuss, who is sometimes too exuberant, here finds theright tones for Mr. Holland, from youthful cocksureness to the gentleinsight of age. His physical transformations over 30 years are alwaysconvincing. Glenne Headly has a more thankless role as his wife, but watch her handle the scene where she suddenly sees something she had not suspected, and intuitively knows how to deal with it. The supporting cast is all strong, especially Jay Thomas as the football coach who becomes Holland's lifelong friend.
this film, falling into its rhythm, appreciating its sweep, I could not help
but remember my own high school teachers. Sitting here at the keyboard, I began
a list of their names, only to realize that you have your own list. Amazing,
how clearly I remember their excellence, and their patience. One anecdote will
Hynes, who taught us Shakespeare, always addressed us as "Mr." and "Miss," as a college teacher would do, and somehow that brought a greater seriousness to "Macbeth" and "Julius Caesar," which were uncharted new worlds for us. Modifying the curriculum to make it more "contemporary" and "relevant" is doing an injustice to students, whose lives will become relevant to the exact degree that high school encourages them to outgrow themselves, and escape from the contemporary into the timeless. Mr. Hynes knew that. So does "Mr. Holland's Opus."
This message came to me from a reader named Peter Svensland. He and a fr...
A clip of Gene Siskel & Roger Ebert defending Star Wars on ABC.
A piece on the experience gained from seeing bad movies.
An interview with Michael Shannon about the election, "Nocturnal Animals," "The Night Before" and more.