Roger Ebert Home

Blog

Movie Answer Man

Spike vs. Clint on Iwo Jima

Q. Recently there has been a press argument between Spike Lee and Clint Eastwood. I'm wondering what you think of Lee's accusations. Spike Lee is a talented, original voice in American filmmaking, but what he has to say about "Flags…

Roger Ebert

In search of redemption

View image Kari Sylwan plays the maid who cradles a dead woman (Harriet Andersson) in Bergman's "Cries and Whispers." One of the most prolific and intelligent contributors to the comments section of the blog is Solomon Wakeling. I wrote in…

Scanners

What makes a movie a "classic"?

View image I wasn't old enough to experience the French New Wave first hand. My introduction to the New German Cinema (Fassbinder, Herzog, Wenders, et al.) was getting my mind blown by Werner Herzog's 1973 "Aguirre, the Wrath of God"…

Scanners

Hitchcockian chills

Hitchcock I've been loading my thousands of CDs (most of which have been in boxes for about three years) into iTunes in recent weeks and it's been quite a revealing experience. (It explains, for one thing, why I've never been…

Scanners

Tell me a story... or don't

View image Batman vs. Joker. How much story do you need? Is this movie going to have an unambiguously happy ending? What do you think? "I'm a storyteller." That's the way many of the great old Hollywood directors used to…

Movie Answer Man

NYC too small for Hulk, Spidey?

Q. I'm still wondering why it's so tough for Marvel to reconcile psychological extrapolation and pure action with the Hulk. Having seen both incarnations, they're vastly different movies, and I'm still curious why it's so tough to dabble in the…

Roger Ebert

Triumph over "Triumph of the Will"

I've just finished viewing Leni Riefenstahl's "Triumph of the Will" (1935) for the second or third time, and it will be a Great Movie published June 27. Whether it is truly great or only technically qualifies because of its importance…